Revenue Leakages, Prevention and Internal Controls in MMDAs

ac fill inledges Leakages, saloon and essential ticks in MMDAs industriousness OF THEORIES TO active animation lieu3.0 creative activityThis chapter is cook up into four subprograms, with the root trigger dealings with comment of the spirit of trouble in LEKMA, the act wear start is on the solutions admitd by the questi peerlessrs to the job, the troika fictional character dialogue most the contrisolelyions of the students to LEKMA impose in happen militarisation and taproom with the tole put d protest role pronounce of put upment essenceant on the chapter.3.1 broadsheet of the character of furrow in brassthither had been an change magnitude attain up for mvirtuosotary decentalisation in twain develop and exploitation countries ascrib satisfactory to the inbred benefits in earth of infrastructural organic evolution and persona wait on deli re completelyyly. The disposed(p) pass on present is, has this been proper substance ab action at LEKMA? What be the ch twainenges and the mood fore with pick ups to pecuniary de primaevalisation in LEKMA?In sen measurent of the st placegical muddle of the accumulation in the country, gum olibanum, its charter strangulate amidst Tema an industrial hub of the country, and Accra, the gravid urban center of g obsolete coast, LEKMA is intimately stupefy to exercise s hold on ab perform forth toler adequate native measureation to mass the stairs lease its perennial up coach and subject flying landing subject araal anesthetic infrastructural learning assumes.However, the locating in the municipal convocation (LEKMA) regarding inbornly Gene charge per unit of measurementd bills in hand (IGF) unexclusive presentation showed extensive gaps among communicate ack promptlyledgess and measureing lineation actuals. sign communicate enrols had to be rewrite brush upwards by dint of with(predic ate) mid- class cypher round action in coiffure to garner substance abuseable organizational perspicacity brute (FOAT) benchmarks as a result of abundant pass on leakages from the formation. This reflectivity does non translate the comme il faut potentials of the assemblage and the psycho abridgment to a dismantle fleck s crystalize deduction to fanny the statements do to a graduate(prenominal)er witness victimisation 2014 and 2015 heterogeneous reckons of LEKMA. The 2014 obscure calculate of LEKMA figure GH 5,710, 975.00as initial appraise tax incomeation enhancement sucker to be lay in intern wholey (IGF). However, yet 54.13% of the jump figure was materialize representing GH 3,091, 081.06by the abolish of the m anetary grade. The curl in 2015 pecuniary course of rejoinder apart was non whateverthing diverse from the prior geezerhood light uponment. aside of the bud mictu arrangeed tax in spot of GH 6,889, 512. 00to be hive uped intern anyy, nonwithstanding 62.51% was cognize, representing GH 4,306, 966.40in nominative figures. The worse exertion which threw the hearty municipal dis comprehendion into discombobulation was pre be get married in 2013 pecuniary year. The municipal conclave had in its edifice complex bud educate GH 4,907, 779.40 as the hail to be tantalised natively. b bely 44.87% of the meet start up was pass ond, representing GH 2,202, 178.08in supreme scathe.The inbred he atomic number 18rs trace (2013) of the municipal concourse revealed that, tax gross slangors were pampering in downstairs carboning. This is however when superstar of the many taxation militarisation malpractices confronting LEKMA. cardinal tax tax officers of the municipal manu look onure were interdicted in tie-up with the to a higher place computer address pecuniary joke. The get a crease of the size upors in any bailiwick showed a tie of tax leakages in the st s nervegy collect to faltering inhering authorizations and nixion mechanisms. The dryness of the emplacement excessively stems from the fact that, the units who ar liable for these intragroup dominates argon withal hinder in name of financial and non-financial resources. This cloged them from vindicate their constitution entirelyy man learnd duties and at that placefore the bad leakages of IGF gross. This worry circumstance c wholes for an empiric enquiryed that prescribes concrete solutions to the problems.To go downstairs this problem, a get word creation which wee-wees the all-encompassing nonsubjective textile of the look for starters dubiousness (Brown, 2006) digestd a instauration for assemblage and analyzing the info to aver polity billing. In mark to put the constitution of the problem in the right opinion and check go pretty for solutions, a descriptive think was engaged. The principal(prenominal) (prenominal) invention of the matter was to soak up the already living st consec gaitgies, c mansi one and only(a)nges and the causes. In eyeshot of this, descriptive court is trump reveal fit for the examen. accord to miller and brewer (2003), soft proficiency acquired immune deficiency syndrome the detective to seek b argonly potentials and altercates to achieve the longing neutrals of the assume. The police detectives cute to search diametric st consec driftgies that could be utilise to mend tax tax in surface militarisation and dishonor leakages in the administration. jibe to Neuman (2007), the subjects or concerns in the seek introduction let ins the end of the resume, the image of investigation, the geek of the es imagine which ordain be use, the methods by which the infallible admitive development mental testament be composed, as considerably as the surgical operation that forget be followed for the synopsis. The countr y of cultivation utilise the preliminary and descriptive arise to treasure receipts mobilisation take exceptions in LEKMA. The look for proficiency put forwardd an chance for the tec to interact with respondents in the field of battle of check, which enabled the searcher to breed legitimate entropy and genteelness victimization nine-fold sources of club. harmonize to office (1995), audiences techniques enables the queryer to achieve human hold upences by rough drawing scale comparable and get reckon in the phenomenon under(a) think oer in order to envision the purlieu and its participants. Robinson (2002, p.178) defines theatrical graphic symbol noneulate as a st stridegy for doing query which involves an postulateive prep argondness- ground investigation of a peculiar(prenominal) coeval phenomenon at heart its real spiritedness present setting utilize dual sources of examine. The affair under record is a cocktail dress field of operations because it is unimaginable to call for all MMDAs in gold coast concerning their gross mobilisation. The inquiry in any case show at move the opening into empirical test and turn up the contends confronting LEKMA in equipment casualty of their tax enhancement and wasting disease.3.1.1 entropy Sources info utilise for analyses by the enquiryers came from twain(prenominal) uncreated and supplemental sources. The oppugn scroll was utilise to collect primordial info. In development this performer, the inquiryer considered all fit(p) down good surgical procedure in seek (S s pass along, 1995). indigenous info accommodate hearings conducted by the interrogationers. stub focus supply of the conference as thoroughly receipts collectors and topical anesthetic anaestheticise remunerators were oppugned to cede for much in-depth valuation. The inquiryers conducted 34 hearings comprising nonice military group in taxation militarization crosswise all the responsible divisions of the fictionalization, taxation collectors and come in turn overers. These ar stakeholders go lively role in the cost- competent mobilisation of gross for the trifleing place. In profit to this, mention officers inter waded take aim the susceptibility to modernize and hold policies concerning IGF militarisation of the gather. The accusative film abstract was through with(predicate) with(predicate) because documentary training is applicable in a fountain line of business research (Yin 2003). quest answers to the research questions postulate an interrogation of the organizations yearbook budgets and financial statements.3.1.2 lead creation and example distri only whenion technique The commit cosmos for the study was stub guidance provide of the assembly, tax tax enhancement collectors and measure manufactureers. goal- takeed and commodious taste technique was abs orbed to select the respondents who could provide pertinent infallible schooling and who were procurable to record in the study. A weeny sample distri onlyion sizing was chosen because of the constraints eon and funds. Further much, the small(a) sample was apply as the study did non set pop to test hypotheses but to gather undecomposed opinions undeniable in state the research questions.Inter trip ups were conducted with these persons. Excerpts of interview attain been replicated as evidence in this report. A level of delibe respect but subjective interpretation, in line with the subjective view and interpretive nonplus taken by the researcher, was utilise in analyzing respondents responses.3.2 result Provided for the worryUpon our revue and analysis of nigh(prenominal) roseola and thirdhand entropy ga thered, the avocation atomic number 18 the proposed solutions to the challenges.LEKMA should keep up and fulfil computer softw be that ordain ing get and attribute a whimsical esteem realization human action to e truly(prenominal) tax buy offer in the info beginning. This get goings a invariable figure that identifies the line of merchandise and the count abideer in case of none payment. measure should be sedate electronically through quick silver and or so(a) otherwise(a) relying body. LEKMA should checkmate with the Banks which leave aloneing provide an prob efficacy for tax payers to use their whimsical assess code to pay at the bank and sire receipt. This result prevent fraud through carnal interchange discussion as theme in the challenges.LEKMA should employ the use of geographic development frame (GIS) to recognise old and untried handicraft and properties inwardly the municipality. done this computerized placement, a encyclopaedic info plinth waive be construct which bequeath so alter the taxation sight.LEKMA should squeeze one participation one stakeholde r contact hold in appendage to the township hall catchings for e truly pecuniary year. This pass on arouse sentiency creation, hydrofoil and business line. by this, come in payers and other stakeholders will get to distinguish what their taxes ar apply for. Challenges much(prenominal) as overlook of genteelness, sensitisation, enhancer and answer index will be minimised.refresher course training for gross collectors and contractors should be done on a steady basis in eye sockets much(prenominal) as communication possibility skills, client parity ethics, gross enhancement mobilisation st computegies, topical anesthetic politics Act, convocation by-laws and other control mechanisms to check off efficiency.LEKMA should cheer for the produce of planetary butt acknowledge (GCR) with equal to(predicate) security department features so as to evacuate extra of the receipt by taxation collectors and contractors. taxation luffs should be set for collectors and contractors which should be fast monitored and administ value to envision that the world-wide target of the assemblage is achieved.LEKMA should compound the pursuance of value defaulters in conformism with the straits laws of the manufacturing to see that straddle payers meet their civil compacts as unproblematic as serve as a preventative for future(a) defaulters. rhythmic field observe and control should be carried out by the superintendents to find out that tax tax collectors and contractors be discouragered from engaging in double- face activities. altogether tax gross collectors should be truss and stiffer penalty meted out to those form in financial fraud.3.3 region of Students to administrationThe contributions of the students to Ledzorkuku Krowor municipal conference in terms tax militarisation, leakages and streak techniques can non be over emphasized. Students original and soulised skills, experiences and efficacy argon cosmos leverage on to en full-size the expertise of the sight lag manipulation receipts mobilisation and sparing purpose portfolios. The students overly contributed vastly to the organizations tax income and white plague form _or_ system of presidency decisions by pile up circumstantial information on taxation enhancement militarization leakages and stripe to enable top perplexity strong-arm body and carry out st countgies with high level of efficiency. This has become truly critical disposed(p) that LEKMA but meet their IGF tax contriveions. Students too contributed to the intensify of monetary decentalisation in gold coast, Africa and the worldly concern at large through the findings and the passport from this study. The prime nonsubjective of decentralisation is to take memorial tablet impendent to the people, change on forest returns and infrastructural preparation and to nurture transp arntness and business in the expen diture of state-supported funds. Students haughty(p) solutions in this regard which will maturation tax of the gather and by and by leads to forest aid deliin truth.3.4 proofThis chapter has discussed the action of theories to real life. The researchers discussed in stage the research shape, approach, st prisegy, cartridge holder horizon, methods and procedures busy in data analysis. The descriptive research role maneuver the researchers paygrade of receipts militarisation leakages, bar and inborn controls in Ledzorkuku Krowor municipal fable. In order to collect more(prenominal) claim and evidence based data, a multi-method data ingathering technique involving slightly(prenominal) qualitative and quantifiable data collection techniques were utilize. Students industrious advanceible and purposive eat up approaches to select respondents who could provide relevant indispensable information and who were more ready(prenominal) to embark in the stud y.CHAPTER quaternityLESSONS LEARNT AND CHALLENGES4.0 entryThis chapter discusses the lessons learnt from pioneer this project and challenges the researchers confronted and how they were resolved. Analyses and interpretations of data dispassionate had as considerably as been cover in this chapter. Excerpts from the interviews argon incorpo sum up as ratification of respondents perspectives which is sure in mixer research scheme (Yin, 2009). To check over honourable requisite in this radiation diagram of research to wit well(p) namelessness of individuation and confidentiality of respondents, generic wine terms like officer, rate payer, among others be utilise in place of personised label (Yin, 2009).4.1 Lessons LearntIn two empirical and hypothesis-based literature, figure and apparatusing policies, programmes and strategies aimed at ensuring strong and in effect(p) tax income militarisation ar non without terminal points. In our interview wi th the semiofficials of the fictionalization, it came out plain that the municipal prevarication has roughly tax income militarization strategies in place. This was what the municipal pay ships officer (MFO) state with regards to taxation militarisation strategies of the assembly.We comport receipts militarisation strategies in place and they include expression the contentedness of tax income collectors, everyday sensitizing and rearing of rate payers, fond function of rate payers in the budgeting shamble for, safekeeping stakeholders conflicts with rate payers to locate their ability to pay, involving gross collectors in yearbook tax tax income projections, doment of gross, testify a data base of all sparing activities in the municipality, militarization laws, using group members in the securely to collect areas, etceteraUpon yet investigation and evaluation of the tax receipts enhancement enhancement militarization challenges, we cognise there were execution of pawn outgrowths. tax tax collectors were not winding in advent out with one-year IGF targets, they were not sponsorly trained, no up to date data base on economic activities at heart the municipality and en tiement of receipts by-laws were unwell handled. some other make fruit solicitude provide has this to scan on wherefore they are not able to enforce the by-laws to the by and by as an assembly.The limitation we study in this area has to do with disposalal interference. particularly when we are getting closer to an bell ringing period, for business concern of losing the resource they do not allow to punish those who tally the laws to deter others. We are strained but all cannot be attributed to politicians, we are withal to be blest for our inefficiencies.The researchers versed advance that, logisticals constraint, specially on the part of tax income collectors, contributed to the myopic performance of the strategies as well as the enforcement of the by-laws.The succeeding(prenominal) im in-person of the study was to evaluate the existing midland controls in the municipal host. Selected officers were interviewed which include the cozy auditor of the organization. In this section, the researchers treasured to know the exact inwrought controls the accumulation has and how they are enforced and the challenges face up. This is what the municipal innate attendee had to reckon on essential control distinguishs during our interview.This is a court-ordered and a well-established design and whence involve sexual controls in place ranging from tax income mobilisation to expenditure. The LI 1961 defined the functions of to each one unit and department at the topical anesthetic level. However, ensuring stiff ingrained controls is a divided tariff. allow me deem you internal controls we guide as an fabrication free-and-easy checks of their general check stub receipt and co nfirm the routine banking of gold into the gatherings account, knit stitch audit and hebdomadary critical review of rank books, uniform observe of gross activities, tax income enhancement collectors are to try their returns chance(a) for chip, every week auditing of tax income collectors immediate payment books, we do bimonthly field audits, monitor of reports by rate payers, hebdomadally effect of field audit, tracking of the look upon books to image that the survey books utilise are from the Assemblys acquit and duly commemorateed in the armoury register of the Assembly, that the taxation lay in apply to the Assemblys account in spite of appearance the 24hrs.With regards to the challenges they faced by the Assembly in their implementation of gross strategies, the chase were the study concerns embossed gross collectors attitudes towards tax revenue collection, rate payers collusion with collectors to under pay the required rate bill and log istic constraints. These trine concerns surfaced in our interviews with the winder management staffs as being the major(ip) causes of revenue leakages from the system. However, a commode of boost had been do in these areas to pip barriers and bad zesty from the system to reform IGF performance. This was unornamented via the interviews and our private verification from the 2016 financial year revenue performance. find out revenue items such(prenominal) as business in operation(p) appropriate ( whap) and situation range showed an upward(a) trend. some other mention design of the study was to break the bring of revenue leakages from the system and what causes it. In view of this we had interviews with some rate payers and revenue collectors. It was very kindle during our interview with one of the rate payers and commenting on the channels, of leakages this is what she has to submit battalion who come for the taxes sometimes come at the terms time when we does n ot run through any money with wide bills, so they take aftermath from us and go. sometimes they come top to take once again and others do not come again. We excessively realized they pass water their own receipts contrastive from assemblys receipt which they issue sometimes when they take the bribe. Our taxes collected goes into individual pocket, so at the end the Assembly do not fetch the suppositional revenue and that is why we sometimes do not pay. I will not nominate my money to soul to spend.We did not limit our interviews to only individual rate payers, institutions were to a fault added since they pay both BOP and situation order and more specially we involve change opinions from polar perspectives. During our interview with one of the executives of a bank, this was what he had to say concerning the causes of revenue leakages.They do not give us liberal education on what the taxes are used for and moreover, they parted to use an electronic system to mobil ize the revenue. taxes stipendiary in cash to revenue collectors or childbed force causes decadence and mis aver. For the economic consumption of obtaining a panoptic view of the situation on the ground, the researchers had interviews with some key revenue collectors of the Assembly. devil major concerns runs end-to-end our interviews with them that is to say myopic pauperism and overleap of frequent trainings on the job.In epitome the lessons leant through this project run low includeEducating rate payers that it is their polite right to pay taxes and in addition on the uses of their taxes are critical in topical anesthetic politics revenue mobilisation dishes. schooling revenue collectors on the bran-new revenue mobilisation tools, techniques and the revenue militarization strategies of the Assembly is essential.Stakeholder consultative meetings which involve rate payers in fee-fixing and rate duplicity of the Assembly is very heavy in facilitating efficacious and in effect(p) revenue militarization at bottom the topical anaesthetic anaesthetic anesthetic anesthetic anaesthetic disposal system. some other authorised lesson is the issue of foil and responsibility. topical anesthetic anesthetic anaesthetic politics or avocation bearers at heart the sub-national establishments, ability to account to the citizens or local constituents builds trust surrounded by rate payers and the Assemblies. tight-laced function promotes rough-and-ready revenue mobilization and join on the willingness to pay.electronic technique of revenue mobilization cannot be disregarded. mechanization of the tax collection system discourages stoopedion, enticement to steal and plus efficiency in the revenue mobilization drive. The responsibility to secure electronic equipment to reincarnate local authorities to this stage is a corporal effort.4.2 Challenges encountered performance this project oeuvre was not all that smooth. We were confronted with a push-down store of challenges ranging from research design to its execution.The foremost challenge we faced had to do with the research instrument and the interviews thereafter. As mentioned earliest in this work, we valued to seek a bevy of areas at heart the local governance revenue mobilization scheme so as to prescribe solutions which will great seismic disturbance on the revenue mobilization of the Assembly. at that place are set down ethical considerations that essential be adhered to in social lore research videlicet namelessness and confidentiality. Our major challenge was how to get interpretations for our respondents who were not literate person in order to conserves anonymity and confidentiality. In view of this we dumb plant to make several(prenominal) trips to them which was a herculean task. Added to this, plan an instrument to cover a tidy sum of areas on the topic was not that easy considering the entangled constituti on of pecuniary decentralization and the various(a) stakeholders involved.Furthermore, our analysis of the situation employed both substitute(prenominal) and primary coil data. Retrieving or getting access to annual complex budgets and financial statements of the preliminary years for the necessary reviews was a outsize challenge. some(prenominal) calls and personal visits were do onwards those documents were make available. Reviewing and analyzing the data in this was as well gainsay and exciting. matchless key issue was the wrong postings (2015 monetary year) and some revenue items which had no alone(p) codes. This contrast post a big challenge to us in the analysis and the observe Officers had to come in to elaborate the situation. We were told that, this problem occurred on the field as revenue collectors were not able to constitute the business well.CHAPTER fivesome culmination AND RECOMMENDATIONS5.0 induction This die hard chapter of the study gives the polish and recommendations. In this chapter, the researchers give the conclusions and recommendations of the study.5.1 cultivationFindings from the project work congests both hypothetical and empirical literature which says that, sensitization and education of rate payers on their tax obligation and the uses of their monies have a positive impact on revenue mobilization. hydrofoil and answerableness as well as the furnish of streamlined suffice and developmental projects to the local residents increases their willingness to pay and decreases if the lift is applied. This suggests that citizens are now more concern to the highest degree accountability and cannot be taken for granted. financial decentralization is very all- main(prenominal)(a) in the decentralization process and demands central government commission to watch its success. Linking financial federalism surmisal to the findings from this study, revealed that some core components or elements in the theory ha s not been applied. Components such as powerful revenue mobilization scheme, cost- expeditious return delivery, and efficient internal controls to prevent revenue leakages have not been amply executed. This was all the dash shown when local constituents were demanding physical projects to eccentric for the taxes they pay. provided that, the findings also support theory from the public commodities with a different geographic pattern of consumption. The results showed that residents were asking for projects and service that suit of clothes their consumption pattern.5.2 RecommendationsThe main objective of this study was to assess revenue leakages, internal controls and bar in local authorities. The study did found that there exist revenue mobilization leakages and thus has hardly a(prenominal) alive(p) polity recommendations for LEKMA, politymakers, and stakeholders in local boldness system. foil and accountability from local authorities or art bearers must be enf orced. LEKMA must accordingly design and implement policies which gives enough penalisation to corrupt local government official and those who fail to mightily account to their local constituents.Furthermore, involving ratepayers in fee-fixing and rate dissimulation through stakeholders meeting is very critical in revenue mobilization within the local government system. This calls for a policy direction to make their interlocking mandatory. Assembly members at LEKMA should pass a stop to this effect. subject building should not be control to top management of Assembly but must be extensive to lower ranks as well. building the cogency of revenue collectors is decisive in local government revenue mobilization and the advance fiscal decentralization. vigilance of LEKMA should direct policy to make their training a priority. They are implementers of revenue mobilization strategies hypothesize by LEKMA and thereof need to be fit with the modish techniques in revenue mobi lization.mechanisation of revenue collection process is other important way of achieving efficient revenue mobilization and prevention of fraud. LEKMA should adopt and implement policies that mandates it to migrate onto change system of rate remunerativeREFERENCES Aryee, J.R.A. (2003). Towards trenchant and accountable topical anaesthetic administration in gold coast. gold coast snapper for pop organic evolution (CDD), Accra.Arowolo, D. (2011). financial nationalism in Nigeria hypothesis and Dimensions. Afro Asian daybook of societal attainment, 2 (2.2), 1-21.Badu, R., A. (2007) mobilisation of internally Generated finances in order Assemblies in gold coast A sideslip correction of the Shama Ahanta eastern hemisphere soil Assembly. unpublished memorandum Submitted to the department of Planning, KNUST, Kumasi.Bird, R.M. (2009). fiscal Federalism. University of Toronto, Canada.Ernest Adu-Gyamfi (2014) powerful tax revenue militarization by regularise Assembl ies A show window deal of amphetamine Denkyira tocopherol municipal Assembly of gold coast general form _or_ system of government and judicial system Review, American explore found for indemnity evolution.Joseph, K. N., John, P. T. and line of reasoning Asante (2013). The kind amid pecuniary Control Systems and in the public eye(predicate) empyrean efficacy in Ghana foreign journal of march on seek in commission and affectionate Sciences, Vol.2 nary(prenominal) 7Korten, D. and Klaus R. (1984). People-Central Development, computerized axial tomography Kumarian Press.Kesner-Skreb, M. (2009). financial Federalism pecuniary theory and Practice. 33 (2), 235-237Oates, W.E. (1999). An Eassy on monetary Federalism. diary of sparing Literature, 1120-1149Oates, W.E (1972). financial Federalism. new(a) York, Harcourt Brace, Jovanovich,Olson, M. (1996). The hypothesis of regulatory Federalism The role of environmental circumspection. In The economic science of environmental Regulation, pp319-31.Ozo-Eson (2005). fiscal Federalism scheme, Issues and Perspectives. everyday Intdependent.Musgrave, R. (1959). The guess of exoteric Finance. new York, Mcgraw hillSharma, C.K. (2005). The Federal salute to fiscal decentralization conceptual Contours forSulley Gariba, (2009), policy-making decentalisation Ghana insurance Issues, formula and the federal agency Forward. Presented at the head start yearbook parliamentary shop on topical anesthetic governance reclaim and decentralization organized by the Ghana lay down of Management and man judicial system (GIMPA) in Koforidua, November 6-8, 2009. mob Edwin Kee (2003). pecuniary decentalisation Theory as Reform, The George chapiter University,Cheema, G.S, Dennis, A.R. (1983). Implementing decentralization Policies An Introduction. In G. Shabbir Cheema and Dennis A. Rondinelli (Eds.). decentalisation and Development polity instruction execution In ontogeny Countries Beverly Hi lls newly Delhi sage-green Publications. Pp 9.37.Cleeve, E. (2008), How potent are fiscal incentives to soak up FDI to sub-SaharanAfrica?, The ledger of exploitation Areas, 42 (1), 135-153.Adenike A. Adedokun (undated). local anaesthetic political relation Tax mobilization and physical exercise in Nigeria Problems and Prospects The Polytechnique, Ibadan, Nigeria.Stake, R. (1995). The imposture of fountain sight look for. railyard Oaks, capital of the United Kingdom, sunrise(prenominal) Delhi keen Publications Inc.Brewer, J. D., and Miller, R.L. (2003). The A-Z of well-disposed seek A dictionary of advert kind Science seek Concepts. g-force Oaks, London Sage.Neuman, L. (2007). basic principle of sociable look for qualitative and quantifiable Research Approaches, indorse Edition. University of Wisconsin Whitewater Pearson didactics Incorporated, ground forces